n18
NEWS|Current Affairs 
   |

New Delhi: The controversial decision of UPA-II government ahead of general elections to include Jats in OBC category came under judicial scrutiny with the Supreme Court on Tuesday seeking explanation from the Centre for allegedly ignoring the advice of a statutory body to keep the community away from reservation benefits.The apex court said "the matter is serious" and it would like to "peruse the files containing the materials to know whether there was application of mind or not" for coming out with the 4 March notification to include Jat community in the OBC list."The respondent (Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment) is directed to place entire material, records and files," a bench comprising Chief Justice P Sathasivam and Justice Ranjan Gogoi and Justice NV Ramana said."We will examine the issue," the bench said while issuing notice and sought response of the Centre on the two petitions challenging the notification to include Jats in the OBC list and posted the matter for hearing on 9 April.The court said it will consider the plea for stay of the notification after examining the materials and also sought the assistance of Attorney General GE Vahanvati.The notification included Jat community in OBC list in Bihar, Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Delhi, Rajasthan (two districts of Bharatpur and Dholpur), Uttar Pradesh, and Uttarakhand.Senior advocate KK Venugopal, appearing for OBC Reservation Raksha Samiti, an organisation of members of Communities which are included in the Central List of Backward Classes, alleged that it is an "outrageous notification" issued in haste with "vote bank" politics in mind."Before the election, a largesse is given by political party in power to purchase votes," Venugopal submitted and elaborated how "illegal and arbitrarily" the Union government ignored National Commission for Backward Classes (NCBC) advice which is binding on it to include the Jats in the OBC list.The senior advocate said Jats will be like a "creamy layer" in the OBC list and will take away the seats and posts in schools, colleges and government jobs from other community.Besides the organisation of OBC, three other individuals from Delhi - Ram Singh, Ashok Kumar and Ashok Yadav - belonging to OBC category filed the petition challenging the Centre's notification on the issue.They referred to several empirical studies and survey and said Jat community being a socially forward caste will consume substantive portion of the quota of OBC reservation which will deprive the deserving people of other backward classes of the benefit of reservation.The petitioners submitted that people of Jat community have performed much better than those of other castes and the number of those who have got selected for prestigious civil services examination of UPSC is much higher than the number proportionate to their population."In UPSC Civil Services examination of 2012, the number of people belonging to Jat caste selected is 30 out of total 998 candidates from all over India," the petition claimed.Besides, the members of Jat Community have outstanding representation in politics, cinema, academics, administration, sports, judiciary, army and air force, the petition said."Therefore, it is apparent that Jat community is not such socially backward community which should be included in the Central list of Backward Classes and if it is so included it will defeat the entire purpose of reservation envisaged under the Constitution of India, as the inclusion of Jat in the list of OBC will make other backward classes, which deserve benefit of reservation, to compete with people of general class," the petition said.They have sought direction for holding that Jat community is not a backward class and not entitled to be included in the list of OBC and annexed the findings of the NCBC which in its 26 February, 2014 report rejected the Centre's request for recommending inclusion of Jat community in the central list of backward classes. The petitioners alleged that ruling political parties with an intention to woo voters of a particular community decided to make efforts to get a favourable recommendation from the NCBC for inclusion of Jat community in the central list Bihar, Gujarat, Haryana, Himachal Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, NCT of Delhi, Rajasthan (two districts), Uttar Pradesh and Uttarakhand.In furtherance of its intention, the Centre constituted a Group of Ministers to create grounds for interfering in the independent functioning of the NCBC and upon purported advice and recommendation of the GoM, it asked the NCBC to give favourable requisite recommendation for inclusion of Jat community in the central list, the petitions alleged.The apex court asked the Centre to bring all relevant records to show there was proper consideration of NCBC report to reject its recommendation against inclusion of Jats as OBC.The petitioners said despite NCBC decision to refuse to recommend inclusion of Jats in the Central List of Backward Classes for the state of Haryana, Madhya Pradesh, Bharatpur and Dholpur districts of Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh by its report in 1997 and for Delhi by its report in 2010, the Centre under a politically motivated action, framed absolutely illegal rules conferring power to NCBC to review its recommendation. PTI

Give the highest honour, respect to women: President Pranab on Durga Puja

from firstpost

Give the highest honour, respect to women: President Pranab on Durga Puja

New Delhi: President Pranab Mukherjee on Wednesday greeted fellow citizens on the occasion of Durga Puja, saying "let us resolve to accord the highest of honour and respect to women at all times&...


Nobel laureates summit cancelled after visa denial to Dalai Lama

from firstpost

Nobel laureates summit cancelled after visa denial to Dalai Lama

Dharamsala: The World Summit of Nobel Peace Laureates in Cape Town, South Africa, this month has been cancelled owing to denial of a travel visa by the host country to Tibetan spiritual leader the Dal...

China detains human rights activists for supporting Hong Kong protests

from firstpost

China detains human rights activists for supporting Hong Kong protests

Authorities have detained more than a dozen activists across China and questioned as many as 60 others who expressed support for Hong Kong's pro-democracy protests in recent days, campaign groups said...

India-US to reconstitute talks on protecting Intellectual Property Rights

from firstpost

India-US to reconstitute talks on protecting Intellectual Property Rights

India and the US have decided to set up a high-level working group on intellectual property to sort out contentious issues which have been hampering investments.The group will be constituted as part o...

Charges framed against man for forging Ministry letterhead

from firstpost

Charges framed against man for forging Ministry letterhead

New Delhi: A Delhi court has ordered the framing of charges against a man for allegedly forging a letterhead of former Cabinet Minister Krishna Tirath to confirm his railway ticket.Metropolitan Magist...

India not going to joing any coalition against Islamic State: MEA

from firstpost

India not going to joing any coalition against Islamic State: MEA

Washington: India is not going to join "any coalition" in the ongoing fight against the dreaded Islamic State group in West Asia but agreed to work with the US to deal with the "major i...

President Pranab condoles loss of lives in UP train collision

from firstpost

President Pranab condoles loss of lives in UP train collision

New Delhi: President Pranab Mukherjee on Wednesday expressed condolences over loss of lives in the train accident in Uttar Pradesh."I am deeply saddened to learn about the accident in which a num...