n18
NEWS|Current Affairs 
   |
Supreme Court. Photo: PTI

Frowning upon routine adjournments, the Supreme Court has said that speedy disposal of cases was the "primary morality of justice and ethical fulcrum of the judiciary".

"The foundation of justice, apart from other things, rests on the speedy delineation of the list (of cases) pending in courts," said the apex court bench of judges K.S. Radhakrishnan and Dipak Misra in a recent verdict.

"It would not be an exaggeration to state that (speedy justice) is the primary morality of justice and ethical fulcrum of the judiciary," the two judges said.

"Its profundity lies in not allowing anything to cripple the same or to do any act which would freeze it or make it suffer from impotency," Justice Misra said, speaking for the bench.

Holding that the "virtues of adjudication cannot be allowed to be paralyzed by adjournments and non-demonstration of due diligence to deal with the matter", he said: "One cannot be oblivious to the feeling necessities of the time.

"It is devastating to expect infinite patience. Change of attitude is the warrant and command of the day."

The court said this while taking note of 10 years taken by the Rajasthan High Court in deciding whether an appeal in a civil matter pertaining to a piece of land involved a substantial question of law.

The case was instituted in 1990. On Sep 12, 1997, the civil judge (junior division) of Nohar in Hanumangarh dismissed the suit and decreed in favour Noor Mohammad.

The additional district judge of Nohar July 10, 2001 dismissed an appeal against the lower court order by appellant Jethanand.

This was challenged in the high court July 27, 2001. The appeal was dismissed as no one appeared on behalf of Jethanand.

The apex court noted that in 2004 an application was moved for the restoration of the dismissed appeal. This was allowed Jan 9, 2006.

"As the order sheet would reflect, time got comatosed for more than six years and eventually ministerial order of restoration was recorded on 11.5.2010," the apex court noted.

The apex court said: "The proceedings in the second appeal before the high court, if we allow ourselves to say so, epitomizes the corrosive effect that adjournments can have on a litigation and how a list can get entangled in the tentacles of an octopus.

"It is also astonishing that the lawyers sought adjournments in a routine manner and the court acceded to such prayers..."

The judges observed that "unfortunate characteristics of endemic delays have to be avoided at any cost.

"One has to bear in mind that this is the day, this is the hour and this is the moment when all soldiers of law fight from the path. One has to remind oneself of the great saying, "Awake, Arise, 'O' Partha"."

Referring to its earlier judgments, Justice Misra said: "This (apex) court, in different contexts, had dealt with the malady of adjournment and expressed its agony and anguish. Whatever may be the nature of litigation, speedy and appropriate delineation is fundamental to judicial duty."

Noting that in a democratic set up, "intrinsic and embedded faith in the adjudicatory system is of seminal and pivotal concern", the judges said: "Delay gradually declines the citizenry faith in the system."

Holding that the access to speedy justice was a human right, the court said: "It is faith and faith alone that keeps the system alive. It provides oxygen. Fragmentation of faith has the effect potentiality to bring in a state of cataclysm where justice may become a casualty.

"Timely delivery of justice keeps the faith ingrained and establishes the sustained stability."



Tag : #Supreme Court #rape family #speedy justice

Spot-fixing: Cops look for ex-Railways player

from IBNLive

Spot-fixing: Cops look for ex-Railways player

Police claim to have arrested a first class cricketer, Manish, and are on the look out for a former Railways player, Baburao Yadav.


PM talks firm on border with Li

from IANS

PM talks firm on border with Li

The festering boundary row figured prominently in talks between visiting Premier Li Keqiang and Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh here on Sunday as the Chinese leader arrived in India on his maiden overseas tour since taking over in March.

Jagan case: 2 mins submit resignations

from IBNLive

Jagan case: 2 mins submit resignations

The two Congress Cabinet ministers, accused in Jagan Reddy disproportionate assets case, submitted their resignations to Chief Minister N Kiran Kumar Reddy on Sunday night.

DU students petition Sonia on 4yr course

from IANS

DU students petition Sonia on 4yr course

Teachers and students of Delhi University on Sunday marched towards the residence of UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi, demanding the scrapping of the four-year undergraduate programme (FYUP).

Two-finger test violates rape survivor's right to privacy: SC

from in.com

Two-finger test violates rape survivor's right to privacy: SC

The Supreme Court has held that the two-finger test on a rape survivor violates her right to privacy, and asked the government to provide better medical procedures to confirm sexual assault.

HC upholds plaint against artist for painting wife in nude

from PTI

HC upholds plaint against artist for painting wife in nude

The Bombay High Court has refused to quash a criminal complaint against an artist who painted nude and derogatory pictures of his estranged wife in his bedroom

Chhattisgarh: 9 dead in Naxal, CRPF gunbatte

from IBNLive

Chhattisgarh: 9 dead in Naxal, CRPF gunbatte

Eight villagers, including 3 children, and a securityman of elite Cobra battalion were killed in an encounter between security forces and the ultras in Naxal-affected Bijapur.