n18
Menu
NEWS|Politics 
   |

As the elections approach, the debate over opinion polls and exit polls is unlikely to die down any time soon. After a sting operation on the C-voter survey, a pre-poll agency whose surveys are used by various news outlets, questions were raised on both the legitimacy and necessity of these surveys.Political parties have for long opposed opinion polls as and when they found the results going against them. When the pre-poll surveys before state elections predicted a Congress defeat, the party issued an advisory to its workers asking them to not turn up in TV shows based on these polls.In a debate moderated by Rajdeep Sardesai on CNN IBN, right after the C-voter incident, sociologist and political analyst Dipankar Gupta said that just because there have been instances of manipulation, doesn't mean the process should be banned yet.Columnist Vivek Dehejia in his column in the Business Standard counters opinions expressed by other journalists which emphasised that it would be foolish to say that opinion polls actually influenced the voter. Dehejia cites a research by Manasa Patnam which looks at exit polls in India and says that voters might actually be influenced by exit polls.Summarising Patnam's findings, Dehejia writes:"If early voters heavily favour party "A" over "B" - merely because early-voting regions contain a disproportionate share of "A" supporters - there might be a momentum swing in favour of "A", which would not have occurred if a different region had voted first. On the other hand, heavy early support for "A" could galvanise supporters of "B" voting in later phases of the election to come and support their party in greater numbers, and so there might be the opposite impact."If that is indeed the case, then the argument against the existence of opinion polls gains in legitimacy. However, like Gupta pointed out, instead of banning the polls completely, there is merit in appointing an independent regulatory body to keep a watch in these polls.But exit polls aren't the only medium to influence opinion and spread rumours among voters.In this age of social media, it wouldn't be too difficult to make impressions, courtesy the mammoth internet armies most parties have. Word-of-mouth, village meets, informal gatherings - there are more than just one means through which ideas can be spread among voters.Read the complete Business Standard article here.Manasa Patnam's original paper on how opinion polls can influence voters can be found here.

The Ajit Doval power doctrine, and why it is much better than empty Gandhi-giri

from firstpost

The Ajit Doval power doctrine, and why it is much better than empty Gandhi-giri

We have not seen as much clarity in Indian strategic thinking as we are now doing in the words and actions of Ajit Doval, our National Security Advisor (NSA). Speaking in Mumbai yesterday (4 August) o...


Parliament logjam: Will the Rajya Sabha also see 'harsh' Lok Sabha-style suspensions?

from firstpost

Parliament logjam: Will the Rajya Sabha also see 'harsh' Lok Sabha-style suspensions?

The gloves are off and the knives sharpened. A determined Narendra Modi government could now try to replicate the Lok Sabha formula to bring normalcy to the Upper House of Parliament by making a plea ...

Washout of track led to twin train tragedy in Madhya Pradesh: Suresh Prabhu

from ibn

Washout of track led to twin train tragedy in Madhya Pradesh: Suresh Prabhu

Union Railways Minister Suresh Prabhu on Wednesday said track washout due to a swollen Machak river led to the derailment of two trains at Harda in Madhya Pradesh. Making a suo motu statement on the ...

MP train derailments: Suresh Prabhu tells Rajya Sabha he's visiting the accident site

from firstpost

MP train derailments: Suresh Prabhu tells Rajya Sabha he's visiting the accident site

New Delhi: Railway Minister Suresh Prabhutoday said the tracks beingwashed away due to a swollen Machak river ledto the derailment of two trains at Harda in Madhya Pradesh.Making a suo motu statement ...

Your comment on my DNA shows your prejudice against Bihar: Nitish writes to Modi

from ibn

Your comment on my DNA shows your prejudice against Bihar: Nitish writes to Modi

Bihar: Days after Prime Minister Narendra Modi claimed that there is a problem with the DNA of Nitish Kumar, the Bihar Chief Minister has hit back expressing disappointment over his remark. Maintaini...

Parliamentary deadlock: Aggressive Sonia, Rahul may force BJP to dial back its offensive

from firstpost

Parliamentary deadlock: Aggressive Sonia, Rahul may force BJP to dial back its offensive

On Tuesday , Congress MPsin the Lok Sabha didn't enter Parliament. They instead stood outside and, led by party chief Sonia Gandhi, shouted slogans against the Prime Minister accusing him of only indu...

Live: Uproar in Parliament over twin train accident

from ibn

Live: Uproar in Parliament over twin train accident

11.07 am: Amidst din, Railway Minister presents statement on the twin train tragedy. 11.05 am: Uproar in Rajya Sabha as Railway Minister informs the House on the train accident in Madhya Pradesh...