n18
Menu
NEWS|Politics 
   |

The Wikileaks endorsement of Narendra Modi has blown up on the BJPs face.A burst of tweets from Wikileaks has denied that Julian Assange ever did anything of the sort.Heres the BJPs Muktar Abbas Naqvi in full damage-control mode:The nation does not need a certificate from Julian Assange or Wikileaks about Modi, and neither does Modi to win the elections. What the people want is just good governance.Fair enough. Indians often rightly complain about the disproportionate attention given to every bit of foreign attention a Time cover, a New York Times editorial, and now a Wikileaks mention.But then those who complain vociferously turn around and go gaga whenever they see anything vaguely positive about them from the same Big Bad West. Narendra Modi has not been shy about tomtomming crumbs of supposed approval from Wikileaks.Modis own blog went to town about it.Talking about Wikileaks cable about him Shri Modi on Tuesday mentioned, Wikileaks cables are accurate. I am glad to learn that America admits Modi is incorruptible. He noted cable mentioned him fairly and said he was a good Indian leader. He said, to say a person in non-corrupt is one thing but the report that America has sent mentions me as un-corruptible based on interactions with people. (The blog chose to bold that last bit presumably to draw even more attention to it.)That bit of self-aggrandisement has led to the latest social media embarrassment the striking black and white poster with a picture of Julian Assange and the quote attributed to him America fears Modi because they know that he is INCORRUPTIBLE. It was apparently originally created as satire but over-excited BJP leaders happily shared it around as detailed by this blog on Outlook. Thats drawn the quick and sharp Twitter smackdown from Wikileaks for this this fake #Modi endorsement.Wikileaks is a big raw dump of classified data, a mishmash of cables with all kinds of opinions, rumours, speculations. It makes for fun reading because it gives an insiders view into what normally inscrutable diplomats might be really thinking. But its not the voice of an oracle. Cherrypicking within that grabag of opinion and gossip for a gold seal of approval is a fools errand. Now the BJP has ended up with egg on its face for three simple reasons.Assange did not say it Julian Assange is no authority on India. First off, to quote him to bolster Modis credibility in India is ridiculous. Its even more laughable because Assange did not say it and Modi supporters including BJP office bearers passing the photo around did not bother to check. Wikileaks has since tweeted that the incorruptible quote actually comes from Gujarat Congress leader Manohar Singh Jadeja. And even there Jadeja did not call him incorruptible. He said that in Gujarat even Muslims are now supporting him because he is viewed as someone who is incorruptible and can deliver the goods.Corruption is all in the eye of the beholder According to the Indian Express, BJP national vice-president Purushottam Rupala and state party spokesperson I K Jadeja have been over the moon about what the Wikileaks supposedly leaked. They said in a press release "The government which has denied Modi as Modi now finds him as one with strong political willpower, an able administrator as well as the only non-corrupt, no-nonsense politician of India."One should look before one press releases. Nowhere do the Wikileaks give Modi the incorruptible chhappa he and his supporters are boasting about. At one point it says Modi has successfully branded himself as a non-corrupt, effective administrator, as a facilitator of business in a state with a deep commercial culture, and as a no-nonsense, law-and-order politician who looks after the interests of the Hindu majority." But then the same cable goes on to say that big-ticket corruption is alive and well in Gujarat even if Modi has managed to purge petty corruption at the mid- and lower levels of the bureaucracy. It quotes a journalist as claiming that large sums flowed into BJPs party coffers, for example, when Reliance wanted to expand its refinery in Jamnagar. The cable openly admits that those claims could not be verified but given an Arvind Kejriwals penchant for Ambani-Adani crony capitalism histrionics, whats to prevent AAP from giving these claims the Wikileaks seal of approval as well? Does the BJP really want to spend its energy on a Wikifight for the sake of a crumb of perceived praise?Opening a can of worms The BJP has now drawn more attention to the rest of the report. Its effectively opened up an ugly can of worms. In that same Wikileaks, Michael S. Owen, the American Consul-General in Mumbai also had this to say about Modis leadership style.In public appearances, Modi can be charming and likeable. By all accounts, however, he is an insular, distrustful person who rules with a small group of advisorsHe reigns more by fear and intimidation than by inclusiveness and consensus, and is rude, condescending and often derogatory to even high level party officials. He hoards power and often leaves his ministers in the cold when making decisions that affect their portfolios.That sounds like exactly the kind of leadership style that does not work if you are the head of a large, unwieldy and diverse coalition as opposed to a Gujarat. The BJP can dismiss Owens assessment as biased, ill-informed and uneducated. But it cannot have it both ways - brandish the positives as gospel truth and dismiss the negatives as inconsequential and biased.In fact, there is actually something in the Wikileaks cable that directly addresses the qualms many have about Modi and communal relations. The consul-general is clear that he does not think Modi will apologize or back down on the violence of 2002. But he also agrees with another Congress leaders 2006 assessment that communal harmony would actually improve in Gujarat because Modi knew that a recurrence of anything like 2002 would doom his national chances.Owen writes:Ironically the man most hold accountable for the communal violence of 2002 may now be the most ardent defender of communal harmony, at least on the surface.Obviously the BJP cannot come out and say this because it would be digging up the ghosts of 2002 which it wants kept firmly out of sight. But this is really much more of a pragmatic endorsement of Narendra Modi than dressing up other peoples quotes about the incorruptible Mr Modi.

Rajnath Singh calls Emergency a "historical blunder" by the Congress

from firstpost

Rajnath Singh calls Emergency a "historical blunder" by the Congress

New Delhi: Congress committed a "historical blunder" by imposing the Emergency on 25 June, 1975, Union Home Minister Rajnath Singh said on Saturday, while attributing it as the &...


AAP terms Delhi MLA Mohaniya's arrest as 'presssure tactic' by BJP

from firstpost

AAP terms Delhi MLA Mohaniya's arrest as 'presssure tactic' by BJP

New Delhi: Claiming that its MLA Dinesh Mohania was arrested on false charges, Delhi's ruling AAP on Saturday alleged that it was a "pressure tactic" by the Centre and BJP to divert ...

'How to lose a negotiation': Rahul Gandhi hits out at Modi over NSG bid

from firstpost

'How to lose a negotiation': Rahul Gandhi hits out at Modi over NSG bid

New Delhi: After the Congress slammed Prime Minister Narendra Modi over India's failed bid to join the Nuclear Suppliers Group (NSG), party vice-president Rahul Gandhi, who is abroad, took to Twitter ...

Merit or 'skulduggery'? Subramanian Swamy dares Arvind Kejriwal on IIT admission

from firstpost

Merit or 'skulduggery'? Subramanian Swamy dares Arvind Kejriwal on IIT admission

Thiruvananthapuram: Escalating his attack on Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal, BJP leader Subramanian Swamy on Saturday asked him to show courage to admit that he was admitted into IIT by some &am...

Tamil Nadu Congress chief Elangovan quits after electoral setback

from firstpost

Tamil Nadu Congress chief Elangovan quits after electoral setback

Chennai: Tamil Nadu Congress Committee President EVKS Elangovan has tendered his resignation owning up responsibility for the party's poor show in assembly elections after Vice-President Rahul Gandhi ...

Akhilesh Yadav nullifies merger with QED: Will it yield dividends in 2017 polls?

from firstpost

Akhilesh Yadav nullifies merger with QED: Will it yield dividends in 2017 polls?

Dreaded jailed don Mukhtar Ansari's party Qaumi Ekta Dal (QED) will not merge with Samajwadi Party. The proposed merger which was announced with all the required fanfare only four days ago by no less ...

AAP MLA Dinesh Mohaniya arrested: Modi, Jung have handed Kejriwal a loaded gun

from firstpost

AAP MLA Dinesh Mohaniya arrested: Modi, Jung have handed Kejriwal a loaded gun

What are you gonna do when they come for you?Give Arvind Kejriwal more ammo to shoot at youTo have the police pick up AAP lawmaker Dinesh Mohaniya while he was addressing a media conference is taking ...